Professional Song Critique (135)

Tommy Boy is seeking contemporary Party Music (Hip-Hop / Dance) + Critique & Feedback

Tommy Boy is seeking producers and artists who produce their own music and videos and that are on the verge. We are specifically interested in listening to finished demos from currently active Hip Hop and Dance artists, ideally merging both styles. Please submit your best material here, and we will be eager to listen and respond with a Detailed Critique & Feedback.

Getting your music ready for release with advice from The Music Box!

This dropbox is for artists who are seeking production advice on their music or music/sound based productions. Using our experience we aim to help artists get their tracks ready for self release or for submission to labels or publishing companies.

The submission price includes feedback on tracks and we will answer specific questions based on our knowledge and experience.

Get your mix ready for release!

As part of this service we would listen to the tracks in an acoustically treated control room and check overall mix/master levels, balance and phase check as well as listening in mono/stereo through various monitoring systems. This would be the first stage, then we could give feedback based on specific questions and offer our critique on the mix and arrangement from an engineer/producer perspective.
We look forward to hearing from you!

Sean Ross Detailed Review Service

Detailed review and critique of any song submitted, as well as possibility to work with me on my personal projects (if your stuff is hot!).

I'm a producer/songwriter who's worked with Lil Wayne, YONAS, Logic, Brother Ali, Little Brother, Phil Ade, Dipset & Gunit members.

Professional Critique from Tom Perry, Producer for Grey Creek Productions

Tom Perry, noted producer/engineer will review your songs as a songwriter or singer/songwriter or band. Tom has produced or engineered over 30 Gold and Platinum albums. Michael Jackson, Boz Scaggs, Earth Wind and Fire, Diana Ross, Gladys Knight, Paul McCartney,Rick Springfield, just to name a few.
You can check me out on

I will give you a professional and honest critique of you product.
Thanks and looking forward to hearing from you.

Song Critique from Billboard Magazine Critic/Contributor Chuck Taylor

Submit your song and I will provide you a professional critique, telling you straight what the good is and offering constructive criticism about how to improve your potential masterpiece. Each critique will be approx. 1,000 words. As a senior editor, reporter, columnist and single reviews critic at Billboard magazine in NYC for 14 years, I have reviewed music in every genre, from country, pop, rock and hip-hop to smooth jazz, dance, ambient, AC and soul. You will kindly submit a high-quality version of the song you would like critiqued (studio versions preferred over live) along with lyrics and band/artist bio. I will provide a constructive review focusing on the vocal, lyric, arrangement, instrumentation and whatever other particulars you ask me to listen for.

Creative Process and Career Coaching

I have many decades of experience in developing one's original voice. Both as an artist and as a coach to musicians and artists. In addition to 11 solo recordings I've worked with King Crimson, David Sylvian, Vernon Reid, Brian Eno, TOOL, Steven Wilson and Puscifer.

I can listen to your music through, both, your ears (to hear if you are reaching your musical aims) and my ears (to hear how the piece matches up with my experience as a player/producer.) I will give advice, opinions, critiques, commentaries, articulations and 'the works' about where you are heading.

Additionally I run my own record label (7d Media) and am a fully independent musician (recording, performing/touring, producing, licensing, composing and more.) All of my experience and advice is available to you.

Songwriting Critique by Adam Levy (Tracy Chapman, Norah Jones, Amos Lee, and others)

Adam Levy has coached dozens of songwriting students—including undergraduates from the New School and graduate students at NYU. He has numerous original songs and co-writes to his credit—many of which have been recorded by established and indie artists. With his knack for musical and lyrical flow, he can offer insights to help you take your own songcraft to the next level.

Songs Critiques to help you Pitch to the Country Market

We are a publishing company critiquing songs to help you get them ready to pitch for the country market.

Detailed Song Critique

I will provide you with a detailed song critique and advice as to how you can improve your song for radio play/mass appeal. As an artist who has recent commercial FM radio play and as owner/CEO of Concesco Production, I understand what it takes to connect with a wide audience.

Professional Song Critique from Eliot Sloan of Blessid Union Of Souls

Submit your song to Eliot he will provide you with a professional critique to help take it to the next level. Whether it is tips on lyrics, arrangement or melody, he will give it several listens and offer constructive criticism on what can be done to make the best song possible. As lead vocalist and song writer for international pop group, Blessid Union of Souls, Eliot has an impressive track record of hit songs and a knack for hearing memorable melodies to catch the ear of music executives and fans alike. He has worked with artists of several genres including pop/rock, AC, country and R&B so submit your MP3 and let him help steer you in the right direction for your song.

Detailed conversation about your career & songs - emphasis on synch placements

Please submit your best song for a detailed conversation about your career and songs, with an emphasis on synch placement. I am Senior Creative Director and Music Supervisor for Mighty Generation Music, a boutique music publishing and licensing company based out of West Hollywood. I work on a daily basis with television networks, advertising agencies, filmmakers and marketing directors to assist them in finding, securing and/or producing the appropriate music for their projects. I've licensed or created music for hundreds of programs, including Grey's Anatomy, True Blood, Dexter, Private Practice, Breaking Bad, Californication, Sons of Anarchy, The D Monster, Big Breakin', and many many more.

Critiques & Advices from Producer/Engineer/Manager Dick Hodgin

Please submit your best for to Dick Hodgin AKA "The Dream Assassin" for sharp, honest feedback. Dick has a reputation for sharp, HONEST, no punches pulled advice and counsel which has earned him “Dream Assassin” nickname. He has produced, engineered, and/or managed such artists as: The Accelerators Cravin' Melon Johnny Quest Lynyrd Skynyrd Big Daddy Kane Troop 41 J. Cole Jason Michael Carroll Erykah Badu Hootie and The Blowfish Flat Duo Jets Bad Checks Corrosion Of Conformity Far Too Jones Faith Collapsing Confessor Clay Aiken The Ultraviolets and many, many more

Get Hot Critique and Insider Songwriting Tips from Real Industry - Sheena Metal

Hi! This is Sheena, and I want to hear YOU! Let me take my 18 years of working professionally in Los Angeles with major and indie labels alike as a producer, music supervisor, and live music promotions director across many genres, and help YOU avoid some nasty pitfalls in songwriting that can get the best of ideas over-looked! You know you're a genius -- let's make sure everyone else knows it, too. I can't wait to hear what you have to offer the world!

Critique from experienced Producer/Song Doctor
Send me your song. I’ll be happy to give it at least 5 listens before responding with a helpful critique that will take your song to the next level of commercial discovery. With over 15 years of experience, I know what hits and what the next best thing will be. Drop off your song to find out what that is! If you enlist my services additional fees may apply.
Get Your Music Reviewed By The Indie Band Guru
Indie Band Guru ( is a popular music website that gets viewed by many indie music lovers and independent bands. We will give an honest written review of your latest album. Genres we favor are of the indie rock variety. Rap, Urban, Country, and Pop musicians are discouraged from submitting.
Song Critiques and Production advice from award winning artist developer / writer / producer / programer James Sanger

James has been involved in the early stages the careers of 'Dido', 'Keane' ,'Siobhan Donaghy', 'Melanie C' and many a programmer, artist developer, writer or producer. His work having won 3 Brit awards, ( 2 of for best new album) and many Grammys. James's extensive client list includes: ‘U2’, ‘Madonna,’ ‘Dido,’ ‘Phil Collins’, ‘Manic Street Preachers’, ‘Kylie Minogue,’ 'Melanie C', ‘Brian Eno’, ‘Keane’, 'Sinead O'Connor', 'Bryan Ferry', 'Alex James from Blur',' Pet Shop Boys', 'Annie Lennox', 'The Cure', 'Boy George', 'Siobhan Donaghy', 'Lene Marlin', 'Jimmy Somerville', 'The Cardigans', 'Mumiy Troll', 'Bryan Ferry', 'Faithless', 'A1',' Jack Savoretti', 'Suede', 'The Appletons', 'Atomic Kitten', 'Cooper Temple Clause' and many more. James started his musical career as artist and programmer, his sounds and creative programming quickly made an impression with other producers and artists... A search on '' would show you the sound and style he helped create...

Professional Song Review by Devon Jackson
Devon Jackson has written about music and film for a variety of publications-- from Entertainment Weekly and The Village Voice to Rolling Stone and Details. Publicity is the job of getting the print and broadcast media to talk about your music by printing or broadcasting a story, an interview, or a review of your music.
You may submit your music for a professional written review, and possible consideration for a story.
Professional song review with publishing
One detailed, professional song review for your promotional/commercial purposes, and 2. Guaranteed publishing on major social networks. As an option, I may decide to publish this review also on Fabryka Magazine, but this is not guaranteed and depends on your music as well (due to the magazine demographics, circa 1500-2000 monthly views).
Submit music to Brian Steen for a Professional Song Critique
Sony Music Producer Brian Steen is offering to critique your song and help you get it to the next level. He produces a lot of music, so he is very versed at helping make a song really shine. Additionally, if something is undeniably good, he will reach out to you to talk about how he can help shop it around.
Get a professional song critique from Steve Tramposch, Platinum A&R, Manager, & Producer
Services are led by Launchpad's founder Steve Tramposch, whose 17+ years industry experience features a number of successful titles as an Manager, Producer, and Senior A&R executive for several of the world’s leading music companies, including Capitol, Virgin, Elektra, Eleven Seven, Billboard and more, where he’s been instrumental in the early discovery of numerous artists signed across multiple genres that would later result in the worldwide sale of tens of millions of albums. Steve has been privileged to work with some of the biggest artists, labels and executives in the music industry.